To Sail Beyond the Sunset by
Robert A. Heinlein
My rating:
4 of 5 stars
What a fascinating book on revisit. There's truly a ton of great things about it... and an extraordinary amount of culturally and probably ethically and morally problematic things about it in equal measure.
If you know, you know.
But if you accept the book as a truly groundbreaking SF that fills its pages with joy, acceptance, fearlessness, and a truly excellent amount of World As Myth worldbuilding that elevates stories to reality and jumps beyond the plain discovery stage of exploration and right into the heart of childlike wonder when it comes to time-and-worldline joy of discovery, this really IS the best of all novels.
It's healing, utterly charming, and a great capstone to Heinlein's career... and his last book before his death.
So, what's actually problematic?
That's just it. I'm my own Mrs. Grundy. My own hang-ups and opinions, biases, and they are in direct opposition with the insistence of Maureen Johnson, AKA Lazarus Long's mom. Or Lazarus, himself. But the fact that it is a true cultural norm and everyone is perfectly happy with the actuality of what is happening, it's hard for me to outright condemn it.
And that's kinda the whole thing, right? You show a society where it is truly natural and not a medical or cultural issue, where each and every individual is perfectly happy to go on like this, and they all have perfect freedom to be whatever they wish, and it really IS a true SF novel in every respect. Because it shows us an idea... and the real conflict is between the reader's preconceptions and the existence of a HAPPY PEOPLE.
Of course, our actual world keeps showing us the really dark sides of sex, power imbalance, slavery, injustice. And we keep getting enraged by pedophiles and molestation, for very good reasons. And the damage being done cannot even be quantified.
But then we have a novel of healthy people. The conflict is very real, very fascinating, and absolutely disturbing.
It's problematic to actually recommend this novel at all. But strangely, that's perhaps the best reason to recommend it. Not because it apologizes for the assholes of our timeline, but because it shows us that good people can do some very DIFFERENT things that is hard for us to approve of.
Does this say more about me than the author? Perhaps. I have a strong sense of justice and I draw very strict lines about what I think is right and wrong. I don't generally plop THAT bag of worms on a book review tho, because books are their own beasts and I have a great imagination and I am generally able to let them be what they intend to be. Like To Sail Beyond the Sunset.
I'll just say one thing. For an old man, Heinlein is TRULY one of the most SEXED UP PEOPLE in history.
Fascinating, no matter how you stretch it.
And now that I've gone through a re-read of all his novels, from the first to the last, I am quite satisfied. Some got better with time, some less so, but what a great writer. Challenging, but always super readable.
Bravo, Dean.
View all my reviews