Songs of Earth and Power by
Greg Bear
My rating:
5 of 5 stars
I originally read this ages ago, back before I went to college, and it seriously stuck with me for my entire damn life. I even avoided re-reading it because of how dear it was to me back in the day, wondering if there would be an impossibly huge amount of cringe within it that would make me ashamed to be myself.
But you know what? I shouldn't have worried at all. We must all dare. We cannot remain afraid of what we are or what we could be.
And now? After curling up with my rare hardcover copy that covers a slight re-write of both The Infinity Concerto and Serpent Mage, and savoring every word, feeling every emotion, I can tell you right now that it is one of my all-time favorite books. And I honestly thought a good handful of Greg Bear's OTHER books were some of my all-time favorite books, being well known for his science fiction--and not the FIRST books he wrote, which were outright FANTASY.
I'm shocked, I tell you. Shocked.
But I let me also give a balanced, thoughtful review about the book, itself:
There are lots of actual cringeworthy things that happen in it. There are obvious flaws. But they are very much human flaws, and fully self-aware ones. It's a true coming of age book. With Michael starting out as a cringeworthy teen, with selfishness and crudity, but also a desire to be better, to learn from his mistakes. And this is what I found most fascinating--it's a tale of actual growth. Or rather, a song of the Sidhe AND of Humans, of gaining, and constantly having to re-examine oneself to improve one's wisdom. And there was a lot that needed to be examined.
This book was REAL on the human level, and unflinching about its own flaws, as if it was the Earth itself, or Bear, himself. And all of these flaws, these pains, these blindnesses, and these glorious growths, were well EARNED.
My original first loves about this tale was primarily about the MUSIC. Mahler's unfinished Tenth Symphony plays an amazingly beautiful and large part in it. And so does other art, be it Coleridge, movie magic, or even the art of wine-crafting--all in the service of creating Songs of Power.
As a fantasy, it's right up there with Earthsea AND The Neverending Story, for much of the same reasons. It's mythical, and appropriately awe-inspiring, imaginative, and even deep. The book is itself a Song of Power, and transformative to a soul open to it. :)
It's also impressively YOUNG. It feels so YOUNG. And maybe that's something all of us need sometimes. It's not violent, although the stakes are impressively enormous. It's not cruel, although there is plenty to encourage cruelty. It's truly hopeful and balanced, even though it seems aimless at times, and being used like a pawn should never evoke a sense of good humor toward those who have used us.
And yet, I honestly feel wiser, happier, after having read this and having grown with this young, stupid kid, into the man he became.
100% recommend. 1000% recommend.
Personal note:
If anyone reading my reviews might be interested in reading my own SF, I'm going to be open to requests. Just direct message me in goodreads or email me on my site. I'd love to get some eyes on my novels.
Arctunn.com
View all my reviews